Library/Calling Bullshit
Calling Bullshit book cover - Leapahead summary
Listen to Key Point 1
0:000:00

Calling Bullshit

Carl T. Bergstrom & Jevin D. West

Duration15 min
Key Points7 Key Points
Rating4.5 Rate

What's inside?

Explore the art of critical thinking in a world overwhelmed by data and misinformation. Learn how to distinguish fact from fiction and make informed decisions.

You'll learn

Learn1. How to spot fake news in media and online.
Learn2. Tricks to catch lies and manipulation.
Learn3. Spotting wrong use of data and stats.
Learn4. Making smart choices with the right data.
Learn5. Why it's good to question everything.
Learn6. Avoiding digital age nonsense.

Key points

01We gotta watch out for sneaky lies everywhere

In the book by Carl T. Bergstrom and Jevin D. West, they make a strong case for the need to be on guard against the constant barrage of nonsense we face in our daily lives. They argue that this isn't a new thing, but the internet has turned up the volume and speed at which we're hit with it. Bergstrom and West don't see this as just an annoyance, but a real danger to our democratic society. They point to the surge of fake news as a prime example. False information can easily sway public opinion, trick voters, and warp the democratic process. By learning to spot and debunk nonsense, we can shield ourselves from these manipulative tactics and make better-informed decisions. The authors also shed light on the many disguises that nonsense can wear. It's not just outright lies or made-up stories; it can also be the use of fancy words or complicated language to hide the truth or make something seem more impressive than it really is. For example, the term "garbage disposal unit" might sound high-tech, but it's really just a posh way of saying "trash can". Nonsense can also hide in the form of misleading stats and charts. Data can be twisted or presented in a way that backs up a certain story, while ignoring or downplaying evidence that contradicts it. For instance, a company might boast about its rising sales figures while conveniently leaving out the fact that its profits are going down. Another common form of nonsense is sensationalist headlines and clickbait ads. These tactics are designed to grab your attention and stir up an emotional response, often at the cost of accuracy and context. A news article might have a shocking headline that twists the actual content of the story, or an ad might make over-the-top claims to get you to click. Bergstrom and West's main message is that we can't just take information at face value. We need to be skeptical, critical thinkers who can tell the difference between the truth and the nonsense. This means understanding how data can be twisted, recognizing the motivations behind the information we get, and coming up with strategies to shield ourselves from false information. By doing this, we can navigate our data-driven world with more confidence and clarity.

02Paltering is lying without actually lying. Watch out for it

Let's talk about a sneaky little trick called paltering. It's a way of bending the truth without actually telling a lie. Picture this: you're at a used car lot and the salesman is trying to sell you a car that's been in a major accident. Instead of lying about the car's past, he says, "This car has only had one owner." Technically, he's not lying, but he's definitely not telling you the whole truth either. That's paltering in action. Now, why should you care about this? Well, paltering is a big player in the game of spreading misinformation, or as we like to call it, 'bullshit'. It's all about taking a nugget of truth and twisting it, presenting it out of context or in a misleading way. Let's bring in Brandolini's Principle here. This idea, cooked up by a smart guy named Alberto Brandolini, says that it takes a whole lot more effort to debunk bullshit than it does to create it. Take the myth that vaccines cause autism, for example. Despite countless scientific studies proving this wrong, the myth just won't die. Why? Because it's much easier to make up a false claim than it is to disprove it. It takes a ton of research and communication to debunk these kinds of myths. And let's not forget about the role of fake news, especially online. During the COVID-19 pandemic, a lot of people came across fake news. These stories often had a grain of truth in them, but they were twisted and presented in a misleading way. This made them really hard to debunk. So, what's the takeaway here? Paltering is a crafty way of bending the truth without actually lying. It's a big part of how misinformation spreads in our data-driven world. That's why it's more important than ever to approach information with a healthy dose of skepticism.

Calling Bullshit book cover - Leapahead summary

Continue reading with LeapAhead app

Full summary is waiting for you in the app

03The Internet and social media are full of crap

04Don't let numbers and stats confuse you

05Don't trust every graph or pie chart you see

06We need to question more and accept less

07Conclusion

About Carl T. Bergstrom & Jevin D. West

Carl T. Bergstrom is a theoretical biologist at the University of Washington, specializing in infectious diseases. Jevin D. West is an associate professor in the Information School at the same university, focusing on the impact of technology on science and society. Both are advocates for critical thinking and skepticism.

Explore categories