Good to Great

02The Paradox of the Quiet Leader

When we picture a visionary leader, our minds almost automatically conjure up a highly charismatic, larger-than-life personality standing confidently behind a podium. Yet, the data tells a completely different and deeply fascinating story about the people who actually build enduring greatness. One of the most shocking discoveries of Jim Collins's research was the specific type of leadership required to take a company from good to great. The research team expected to find high-profile, celebrity CEOs who were brought in to shake things up with sweeping speeches and dramatic restructuring. Instead, they found a group of individuals who were remarkably quiet, unassuming, and often completely unknown to the general public. Collins coined a term for this specific breed of executive: the Level 5 Leader. To understand Level 5, we must look at the hierarchy of leadership capabilities. Level 1 is a highly capable individual. Level 2 is a contributing team member. Level 3 is a competent manager who can organize people toward a goal. Level 4 is an effective leader who can stimulate a group to achieve high-performance objectives. Most large companies are run by Level 4 leaders. But Level 5 is a totally different paradigm. A Level 5 leader possesses a highly paradoxical combination of deep personal humility and intense professional will. Consider the story of Darwin E. Smith, who was named the chief executive of Kimberly-Clark in 1971. At the time, Kimberly-Clark was a sluggish, traditional paper company whose stock had fallen 36 percent behind the general market over the previous two decades. Smith was not a flashy outsider; he was the company's mild-mannered in-house lawyer. When the board offered him the CEO position, Smith famously questioned their judgment, noting that he lacked the traditional qualifications. He looked like a farm boy, wore thick, unfashionable glasses, and spent his vacations rumbling around his Wisconsin farm on a backhoe. He was incredibly shy and awkward in interviews. However, beneath this quiet exterior lay an absolutely ferocious professional will. Shortly after becoming CEO, Smith was diagnosed with nose and throat cancer and told he had less than a year to live. He informed the board of his diagnosis but stated he had no intention of dying anytime soon. He maintained his grueling work schedule while commuting to Houston for painful radiation therapy, ultimately living another twenty-five years. This same iron-clad will was directed at the company. Smith realized that the traditional coated paper business was doomed to mediocrity. In a move that shocked the business world, he decided to sell the company's core paper mills and invest all the proceeds into the consumer paper products industry, directly taking on immense giants like Procter & Gamble. The media called it a massive mistake. Wall Street downgraded the stock. But Smith did not waver. Over his twenty-year tenure, Kimberly-Clark completely dominated the consumer market with brands like Huggies and Kleenex, outperforming the stock market by more than four times and soundly defeating Procter & Gamble. When later asked about his phenomenal success, Smith simply said, "I never stopped trying to become qualified for the job." This is the essence of Level 5 humility. These leaders never boast. They do not want statues built in their honor. They channel their ego away from themselves and directly into the larger goal of building a great institution. Contrast this with the comparison companies, which frequently hired larger-than-life, celebrity CEOs. A prime example is Al Dunlap, famously known as "Chainsaw Al," who took over Scott Paper Kimberly-Clark's direct competitor. Dunlap was loud, aggressive, and highly focused on himself. He wrote a book boasting about his brutal management style. He slashed the workforce, cut research and development, and temporarily pumped up the stock price to orchestrate a massive personal payout when he sold the company. He enriched himself enormously, but he completely destroyed the long-term viability of the organization. Level 4 leaders like Dunlap often set the company up to fail after they leave, because their ego demands that the company cannot survive without their brilliant presence. Level 5 leaders operate on a totally different psychological mechanism, which Collins calls "The Window and the Mirror." When things go incredibly well, Level 5 leaders look out the window to apportion credit to factors outside themselves—their team, the economic conditions, or even just plain luck. They absolutely refuse to take all the glory. However, when things go poorly, they look squarely in the mirror and take full responsibility. They never blame bad luck or incompetent staff for their failures. Interestingly, the celebrity leaders in the comparison companies did the exact opposite. When things went well, they looked in the mirror and beat their chests. When things went badly, they looked out the window and blamed the economy, the unions, or bad luck. This concept is profoundly applicable to our daily lives and personal leadership journeys. You do not need a massive title to be a Level 5 leader. Think about how you manage your family, your community group, or your small project team at work. Do you constantly seek applause for your contributions? Do you quickly point fingers when a project falls apart? Cultivating Level 5 leadership means doing the hard, unglamorous work of pushing your own ego to the side. It means waking up every day with a relentless, burning desire to achieve excellence in your specific domain, not so you can be recognized as great, but so the work itself can be great. It requires the quiet confidence to let your results speak for themselves. The world may constantly glorify the loud, the brash, and the self-promoting, but the undeniable truth of the data is that enduring greatness is built by people who are brave enough to be quiet, humble, and unstoppably determined.

Continue reading with LeapAhead app

Full summary is waiting for you in the app

Continue reading