
What If?
Randall Munroe
What's inside?
Explore the fascinating and often hilarious outcomes of absurd hypothetical scenarios through the lens of real scientific principles.
You'll learn
Key points
01The Physics Of A Speeding Baseball
Let us kick things off with a scenario that perfectly captures the spirit of taking a simple concept and pushing it to its absolute, universe-breaking limit. We are talking about the great game of baseball, a sport built on precision, timing, and physics. A standard professional fastball travels at around one hundred miles per hour, crossing the plate in a fraction of a second. But what if the pitcher throws the ball just a little bit faster? Specifically, what if the pitcher hurls that baseball at ninety percent the speed of light? It sounds like a fun, superhero-level feat, but when we apply the actual laws of relativity and aerodynamics to this pitch, the results are nothing short of apocalyptic. To truly understand the chaos that unfolds, we have to look closely at how objects move through the air. Whenever a normal baseball flies toward home plate, it pushes through the atmosphere, forcing air molecules to flow smoothly around its stitched leather surface. The air has plenty of time to get out of the way. However, when a baseball is traveling at ninety percent the speed of light, the rules of aerodynamics completely break down. The ball is moving so incredibly fast that the air molecules sitting between the pitcher and the batter simply do not have the time to be pushed aside. Instead of flowing around the ball, the stationary air molecules smack directly into the front of it. These collisions happen with such extreme kinetic energy that the atoms in the air actually fuse with the atoms on the surface of the baseball. Yes, you heard that right! The simple act of throwing this baseball triggers spontaneous nuclear fusion. Each collision releases a massive burst of gamma rays and scattered particles. The front of the baseball is instantly obliterated, transformed into an expanding bubble of incandescent plasma. This is not just a hot baseball; it is a thermonuclear explosion moving toward home plate at a substantial fraction of the speed of light. The sequence of destruction happens in a matter of nanoseconds, far too quickly for human eyes to process or for human nerves to register pain. The intense flood of X-rays radiation expands outward, completely cooking the surrounding air and tearing the electrons away from their nuclei. This turns the air in the stadium into a superheated, glowing plasma. Meanwhile, the pitcher—who just released the ball—is instantly vaporized by the backdraft of radiation. The expanding shockwave of plasma and high-energy particles then reaches the batter, the umpire, and the unfortunate spectators sitting behind home plate. Within a microsecond, the entire stadium is completely leveled, reduced to a massive crater in the ground. The surrounding city blocks are engulfed in a shockwave that rivals a modern nuclear weapon. It is a level of devastation that is hard to wrap your head around, all caused by a single baseball. But here is the absolute best part of this entire thought experiment: Randall Munroe actually consulted the official Major League Baseball rulebook to see how this situation would be scored. According to the rules of the game, if a pitch touches a batter, the batter is awarded first base. Furthermore, the rules state that the ball is considered dead. Since the batter was entirely vaporized by the plasma shockwave, and the ball ceased to exist as solid matter, we can confidently say the ball is indeed dead. The batter, or rather the scattered cloud of atoms that used to be the batter, is technically allowed to advance to first base. Of course, first base no longer exists, but the rules are the rules! By exploring this ridiculous scenario, we actually learn a tremendous amount about particle physics, the speed of light, and the immense energy bound up in mass. It teaches us that relativity is not just some abstract concept reserved for entirely theoretical discussions; it has real, explosive consequences when applied to everyday objects. The sheer joy of this thought experiment lies in how it seamlessly blends high-level astrophysics with the mundane rules of a beloved sport. It shows us that science does not have to be dry or boring. When we ask absurd questions, we force ourselves to look at the universe from a completely fresh perspective, turning a simple baseball pitch into a breathtaking lesson on nuclear fusion and relativity.
02Building A Literal Periodic Table
Have you ever stared at the Periodic Table of Elements hanging on a science classroom wall and wondered what it would be like to build a physical version of it? The chart is so neatly organized, with colorful little squares representing everything from lightweight hydrogen to heavy, mysterious uranium. It is incredibly tempting to think about gathering a solid, brick-sized chunk of every single element and stacking them up exactly as they appear on the poster. But if you actually attempted this monumental interior design project, you would quickly realize that the universe has a very strict, highly explosive way of telling you to stop. Let us start at the top of the table. If you build the top two rows, you are mostly dealing with everyday gases and some relatively harmless solids. You would have a balloon of hydrogen, a cube of solid lithium, a block of beryllium, and some chunks of carbon. You would also have to freeze oxygen and nitrogen to keep them in solid brick form. So far, your physical periodic table is just very cold and a little bit fragile. But as you move down to the third and fourth rows, the chemistry starts to get a lot more aggressive. Things take a fiery turn when you place the pure alkali metals, like sodium and potassium, into your grid. These elements are highly reactive. If there is any moisture in the air whatsoever, they will begin to spark, hiss, and potentially burst into bright flames. You also have a block of pure phosphorus, which is notorious for spontaneously catching fire when exposed to oxygen. Your beautiful, organized table is now a localized hazard zone of toxic smoke and chemical fires. And we have not even reached the truly dangerous stuff yet! The middle rows of the periodic table introduce a whole new level of terror. You are now dealing with elements like arsenic, which is famously toxic, and halogens like fluorine and chlorine. Fluorine is arguably the most reactive and terrifying element we know of. It is a pale yellow gas that will aggressively attack almost anything it touches, including glass, metal, and human flesh. If your fluorine brick is not perfectly contained, it will eat through its container, react with the moisture in the air, and produce highly corrosive hydrofluoric acid. At this point, your physical periodic table is actively trying to melt the room and poison anyone standing nearby. But the grand finale of this terrible idea happens when you reach the bottom rows. This is where the heavy, radioactive elements live. First, you have chunks of uranium and plutonium. While a single brick of uranium is not going to explode on its own, putting it right next to other radioactive materials creates a very serious radiation hazard. You will definitely need heavy lead shielding just to be in the same building. However, the real disaster strikes when you try to create the final row: the superheavy, highly unstable elements. These elements, with names like seaborgium, hassium, and oganesson, do not exist in nature. Scientists create them in particle accelerators, and they typically decay into lighter elements in a fraction of a second. If you magically spawned a solid, brick-sized chunk of these superheavy elements, they would instantly undergo catastrophic radioactive decay. The sheer amount of energy released in that fraction of a millisecond would be astronomical. To put it in perspective, a single brick of an element like francium or a superheavy synthetic element would not just catch fire or melt. It would release a blast of radiation and heat so intense that it would vaporize the entire table, the building you are in, and a significant portion of the surrounding landscape. The rapid decay would effectively be a dirty nuclear detonation. The radioactive fallout would contaminate the area for centuries. What starts as a quirky organizational project ends in a spectacular, city-leveling disaster. But why is this thought experiment so valuable? It brilliantly illustrates the vast differences in chemical behavior across the elements. We often look at the periodic table as a uniform grid, but it is actually a map of physical realities. It shows us the delicate balance of protons and neutrons in an atomic nucleus. The top of the table represents stability, the middle represents violent chemical interactions, and the bottom represents the fundamental limits of atomic structure. When you force these extreme elements into a physical space together, you highlight the incredible forces that govern molecular bonds and nuclear stability. You learn that the universe favors lower energy states, and when you forcefully stack unstable atoms together, the universe corrects that imbalance with extreme prejudice. So, the next time you look at that colorful chart in a chemistry lab, you can appreciate the profound, explosive power hidden within those neat little squares, and be very thankful that they remain safely separated on paper!

Continue reading with LeapAhead app
Full summary is waiting for you in the app
03Aiming Laser Pointers At The Moon
04The Tragedy Of A Half Empty Glass
05Dropping A Steak From Outer Space
06Propelling Yourself With A Machine Gun
07Draining The Oceans Of The World
08Conclusion
About Randall Munroe
Randall Munroe is an American cartoonist, author, and former NASA roboticist, best known for creating the webcomic "xkcd". He uses humor and clear, simple explanations to make complex scientific concepts accessible to the general public. His work often explores absurd hypothetical scenarios using real science.